Diet in Multiple Sclerosis

Healthy Eating boosts longevity Journal of the American Medical Association 

Multiple Sclerosis Therapy Centres (Scotland) Home Page

 

NUTRITION in M.S.

Generally agreed nutritional guidelines for everyone advise us that to maintain our body and nervous system in good health we need to eat more fruit and vegetables and fibre, and less saturated fat.  Advice to those with multiple sclerosis is basically to follow good nutrition, while adding extra sources of essential fatty acids (EFAs). Oily fish are rich sources of two EFA's in the Omega 3 group, and pure vegetable oils, such as Sunflower and Safflower oils, rich sources of linoleic acid, which is part of the Omega 6 group.

A good balanced diet will achieve two objectives:

  • Supply the body with the nutrients it needs to keep healthy, while avoiding potentially damaging ingredients.

  • Prevent excessive weight gain - a  hazard for those who are less mobile than they used to be (and even the "healthy" population is reported to be getting heavier all the time)

There is much scientific evidence indicating that an appropriate nutritional balance and diet have a positive role in MS. Studies looking at the area of the world where MS occurs have shown that its incidence is closely correlated to the consumption of saturated fats. These are present in full fat dairy products, meat and confectionery.
The brain and nervous system are composed of approximately 60% fat, a large proportion of which is derived from the essential fatty acids. Investigations have shown that the levels of essential fatty acids in the blood have tended to be low in some people with long-standing MS.
One of the essential fatty acids is linoleic acid which is found in polyunsaturated oils such as sunflower and safflower. It was demonstrated that patients given unsaturated fats had a reduced number and severity of relapses and Professor R. L. Swank in the USA has been advising MS people to adhere to the low-fat diet for 30 years. His findings of reduced relapses and slowing of the disease progression compare favourably with the natural history of patients on a normal diet.
In the diet recommended by the Therapy Centres, the consumption of essential fatty acids is increased and that of saturated fats decreased. This nutritional programme also includes increased consumption of vitamins, minerals, trace elements and fibre which are important for general health.
A three-year research study on this diet indicated reduced frequency and duration of relapses plus no significant deterioration in patient's condition.

A more recent trial (April 2002) at the state University of New York at Buffalo "suggests that very low fat diet (15%) with supplemental Omega3 Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid was very well tolerated and may have a beneficial effect on diseas parameters in patients with RR-MS"

Top of page

Healthy Eating

Various diets have been recommended over the years, but the MS healthy eating plan has proved most beneficial for the majority of people

Health eating
for MS is based on research
and specifically:-

The incidence of MS varies from country to country.
It seems to be lower where polyunsaturated fats are eaten in preference to saturated.

Scientific research has shown that those who followed the healthy eating plan carefully had fewer, less severe relapses. General health either improved or stayed the same.

People with MS tend to have an altered pattern of fats in the blood. This can be corrected, as long as the healthy eating plan is followed.

Healthy Foods are Readily Available

toss_salad_wooden_bowl_md_wht.gif (13306 bytes)

 

 

 

 

The aim

 

With the increased awareness of the importance of healthy eating, many low fat and high fibre foods, including some convenience meals, are available from food stores. There has never been a better time to follow a Healthy Eating Plan.

This way of eating is low in fat and should include foods high in fibre, vitamins and minerals. Following the healthy eating plan will benefit the whole family, although children under 5 years will need more fat and less fibre. Similar dietary recommendations are made for reducing the incidence of heart disease, certain cancers and for the treatment of diabetes.

The aim is to eat less fat, particularly saturated fat (generally hard animal fats).
See USA govt advice for everyone on fat
However, you still need adequate amounts of polyunsaturated fat (soft vegetable based fats and fish oils). Polyunsaturated fats are made up of smaller units known as essential fatty acids (EFA's) - essential because our bodies are unable to make these substances which have many important functions. For example, they are vital to the immune system, brain and nervous systems.
As nature does not supply us with EFA without some saturated fat it makes it all the more important to keep down the level of saturated fat from other food.

EFA's
"Omega 3"   and "Omega 6"
fish

Oily fish are rich sources of two EFA's in the Omega 3 group, and pure vegetable oils, such as Sunflower and Safflower oils, rich sources of linoleic acid, which is part of the Omega 6 group. The body uses linoleic acid to make an important EFA called arachidonic acid. Liver is an excellent source of arachidonic acid and should be eaten weekly (1/4lb, 100g). More examples are in the table below.

Top of page

Choose 

Avoid   

Fats and Oils

Polyunsaturated margarines, fats and oils, for example Sunflower or Soya spread and Sunflower oil.
Monosaturates, such as Olive Oil.
Corn, Safflower and Soya oils in moderation.

It has been suggested that the equivalent of 6 teaspoons of sunflower oil each day should be eaten, spread through the day. This can be taken as salad dressing (see recipe) or in the form of nuts and seeds.
2 teaspoons of sunflower seeds give the equivalent of 1 teaspoon of oil.
2 teaspoons of sesame seeds are equivalent to 1teaspoon of sunflower oil.

1 walnut or 6 almonds also supply one teaspoon of oil.

Do not use the important oils such as sunflower for frying as the heat changes the nature of the fatty acids making them similar to saturated fat. Use olive oil for any frying as it contains little omega6 and the good monunsaturated oil is unaffected by heat. Try not to use the oil for frying more than once.

French dressing with suitable oil and polyunsaturated salad dressing.



Frequent fried foods, blended cooking oils, butter, lard, hydrogenated vegetable oil, suet, dripping, low fat spreads, mayonnaise or salad dressings made with saturated fats (check the label).

 

FD01107_.wmf (17116 bytes)Fish salmon
Oily fish such as mackerel,
herrings, kippers, sardines, whitebait, trout salmon,
at least three times a week.

White fish, Tuna and shellfish.



Fried fish, although shallow fried in suitable oil may be eaten occasionally. Fish in batter, cream sauce or butter. Fish tinned in unspecified oil.

Meat
MeatLean red meats, poultry, game and offal.
Try to include 1/41b of liver per week.
If you really dislike it, have 2 to 3 servings of lean red meat.
If you eat no liver, you are likely to need vitamin supplements and zinc.


Fatty meat, processed meat such as sausages, burgers, corned beef, luncheon meat, meat pies or pasties and poultry skin (always remove before cooking).

Top of page

Choose   Avoid   
Fruit and Vegetables
Preferably fresh fruit and vegetables (fresh or frozen) in generous portions. Salad/raw vegetables and green leafy vegetables daily. Aim for 5 portions a day (l lb/ 500g). Use olive oil for stir-fry and roasted vegetables. Potatoes - jacket, boiled or mashed and, occasionally, roasted in suitable oil. Chips are not a good idea. Even a portion of sunflower oven chips would contain half the amount of saturated fat suggested for one day.

Chips. Fried vegetables. (A stir fry with suitable oil is 0. K.)
 
Dairy Products
DairyLow fat dairy foods. Skimmed milk preferably, or semi-skimmed. Low fat yoghurt/fromage frais, cottage cheese. Cheese made with polyunsaturated fat, in moderation. Eggs but no more than 3 or 4 a week. 'Healthy Eating' Ice Cream and Sorbets.

'Gold Top' milk, full cream ('silver top'), Greek yoghurt, thick and creamy yoghurt, whole milk bio yoghurts. Hard cheese, including vegetarian and half fat varieties. 'Ordinary' ice cream, cream.
Grains
Bread, preferably wholemeal. Breakfast cereals, preferably wholegrain, such as Shredded Wheat (but Weetabix and bran flakes contain a lot of sugar), porridge and Muesli. Pasta and Rice. Wholemeal and wholegrain products contain more fibre, vitamins and minerals. Home-made cakes, biscuits and pastries made with polyunsaturated fat and (ideally) half wholemeal flour. Bread sticks, water biscuits, crispbreads, tea cakes, crumpets. Shop bought plain biscuits and muesli bars, in moderation.

Muesli with coconut, added vegetable fat or sugar, sugar or honey coated cereals, croissants. Bought cakes and biscuits, "slimming" biscuits or bars.
 
 

Top of page

Choose   Avoid   

Pulses
Peas, beans, lentils and baked beans. Soups made with pulses.

 

 

Nuts and seeds

Sunflower, pumpkin, sesame seeds, hazelnuts, chestnuts, almonds and walnuts.

 

Brazils, coconut, cashew, peanuts, peanut butter.

  Top of page
   

Choose  

Avoid   

Drinks

Decaffeinated teas and coffees, herbal teas, low sugar soft drinks, water and the occasional "Options" or "Highlights" type drink. Make sure that you drink at least 6 to 8 mugs (9 to 12 cups) of fluid a day.



Excess tea, coffee or cocoa (that is no more than 4 cups containing caffeine in a day). Sugary drinks or full fat 'bedtime' drinks such as drinking chocolate.

Alcohol

Aim to have no more than 1 to 2 units daily, with 2 or 3 alcohol free days each week. A unit is equivalent to 1/2 pint of beer or a glass of wine. Further advice can be obtained from your dietician.

 

Extras

Jams in moderation. low fat crisps, or those cooked in Sunflower oil, once or twice a week.

Between meals, seeds and nuts are good sources of EFAs. Fresh fruit.


'Cream of '  soups. Crisps and similar savoury snacks. Keep chocolate, including carob chocolate, to an absolute minimum.

  Top of page
   

Supplements

 Pill bottle

This way of healthy eating is designed to contain all vitamins, minerals and EFA's you need, if followed closely. Supplements can prove expensive and, at worst, dangerous.

Evening Primrose Oil may be taken if desired, but is generally unnecessary because the EFA content is small. Adequate linoleic acid is provided by the polyunsaturated oils in your diet.

Cod Liver Oil is a valuable source of EFA's but has a high vitamin A content and should be avoided if you are eating the recommended 1/41b. of liver a week or taking other supplements which contain vitamin A. Fish oil supplements not containing vitamin A, such as Maxepa, Pulse or Omega 3 fish oils, may be taken if you cannot eat oily fish.

Linseed e.g. Linusit Gold is rich in EFA's and high in fibre and can be a useful addition to the diet. Check with your dietician.

Vitamin Supplements and single nutrient supplements are best avoided unless you definitely have a deficiency or are advised by your G.P. or dietician. Multivitamins may be considered if you are really unable to eat liver or suspect your diet is inadequate. Avoid those which are high dosage. However, if you wish to take a multivitamin, choose one which provides the recommended daily amount (RDA) for a wide range of nutrients.

Remember no amount of supplements can undo the harm done by an unhealthy diet!

Top of page

Ideas
for
Meals
foodcart

Breakfasts
Muesli, bran, oat or whole wheat cereal with skimmed milk, fresh fruit and a few linseeds.
Wholemeal toast with sunflower spread and jam, marmite or tomato.
Baked beans on toast.
Kippers and wholemeal bread with sunflower spread.
Snacks
Fresh fruit, muesli bar, mixed fruit and suitable nuts, wholemeal tea cakes, homemade fruit cake, fruit scones.
Quick Meals
Wholemeal sandwich, sunflower spread and suitable filling such as fish, lean meat, cottage cheese.
Mackerel salad. Jacket potato with filling. Quick pasta. Tuna bake.
Lentil or thick vegetable soup with wholemeal roll.
Sardines or pilchards on toast.
Main Meals
Lean meat (liver once a week) Fish pie. Turkey savoury rice.
Lean meat casserole with extra beans or lentils.
Jacket potato, pasta or brown rice as accompaniments and plenty of vegetables with every meal.
Desserts
Fresh fruit salad. Tinned fruit in natural juice. Sorbet and fruit.
Low fat and low sugar rice pudding. Low fat yoghurt and fresh fruit.
Wholemeal fruit crumble with skimmed milk custard.
Top of page

Top ten
jacket potato fillings

  1. Tinned or smoked mackerel, mixed with a little natural yoghurt or low fat fromage frais.
  2. Low fat soft cheese or cottage cheese with diced peppers and pineapple.
  3. Crunchy low calorie coleslaw.
  4. Diced roast chicken or chopped chicken roll with sweetcorn and a little natural yoghurt.
  5. Baked Beans.
  6. Chopped hard boiled egg and tomato.
  7. Tuna and sweetcorn or peppers, mixed with a little natural yoghurt.
  8. Curry sauce with chopped chicken, sultanas and chopped banana.
  9. Sardines in tomato sauce.
  10. Ratatouille (chopped vegetables in tomato sauce).
Top of page
Other diets

There are several other diets which have been widely publicised as being helpful to people with MS. Some are more extreme than others.

For instance the Paleolithic diet is restricted to foods  which were eaten in the early Stone Age, arguing that the human digestive system evolved to deal only with  these and cannot cope with "modern" introductions such as dairy products, meat from domesticated animals, refined sugar, and farmed cereals. Part of the regime advises cutting out those foods which contain gluten, a component of many cereal crops used for bread and pasta, as an intolerance to this causes some MS-like symptoms. Most nutritionists do not accept that these extreme measures are necessary, but they may help some people.

The most sensible approach to diet, for people with MS as for everyone else, is to find out all you can on general nutrition and make sure that, on the one hand you are eating enough of all the essentials, and on the other you are NOT eating all those foods (many of them delicious and enticing) which make you obese, or any which have been proved to affect you adversely.

There are standard medical tests which will establish food allergies and sensitivities, and your GP can either test you or direct you elsewhere. But bear in mind that a firm which also hopes to make profits by selling you expensive specialised foodstuffs could be a little bit biased in diagnosing whether or not you need them.

Certainly, eating the right foods can help everyone to live longer. See the report of the American Medical association, Healthier Diets Boost Longevity

Top of page

HEALTHIER DIETS BOOST LONGEVITY, 12-YEAR STUDY FINDS
By Ronald Kotulak Tribune Staff Writer
April 26, 2000

Eat healthy; live longer .
A 12-year study released this week in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that people who eat lots of fruits, vegetables and whole grains live significantly longer than those who do not.
As part of the study, over 42,000 women were asked how many of the following recommended foods they ate each week.

1. Apples, or pears

13. Green salad

2. Oranges

14. Sweet potatoes,. . yams

3. Cantaloupe

15. Other potatoes

4. Grapefruit

16. Baked or  stewed chicken or turkey

5. Orange or  grapefruit juice

17. Baked/broiled fish

6. Other fruit juices

18. Dark breads

7. Dried beans

19. Cornbread, tortillas or grits

8. Tomatoes

20. High-fiber cereals

9. Broccoli

21. Cooked cereals

10. Spinach

22. 2% milk

11 Mustard, turnip or collard greens

23. 1% or skim milk

12. Carrots

Eating foods listed in the highly touted Food Pyramid, with extra helpings of fruits, vegetables and whole grains, dramatically reduces the risk of dying from cancer, heart disease and stroke, a 12-year study of the eating habits of more than 42,000 women has found.

Just adding a few more of the recommended foods each week lowers death rates significantly, but the women who ate the most gained the biggest benefit, a 30 percent reduction in deaths from all causes.
 
While the results are promising, the researchers said further studies need to be conducted to verify the extent of the health benefits that can be obtained from eating reasonable amounts of recommended foods and to help clear up some of the growing confusion about the role of diet in health.

"Given the caution that we have not yet proven this to be causal, the message would be that dietary recommendations seem to improve health, and that if you're able to eat more of the recommended foods, that will lead to improvements in your health and lower your risk of dying," said Dr. Arthur Schatzkin, chief of the Nutritional Epidemiology Branch of the National Cancer Institute.

The study, which appears in the current issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association, assessed the role of diet in a large number of women whose average age was 61. Each woman in the study was followed for an average of 5.6 years.

Unlike other studies, which tend to concentrate on single nutrients such as vitamins, fats, calories or fiber, the National Cancer Institute study involved all the food people eat.

Such single-nutrient studies can sometimes lead to confusing results, as was the case less than two weeks ago after a New England Journal of Medicine study reported that a low-fat, high-fiber diet did not appear to lower the risk of colon cancer. Schatzkin, who also participated in the colon cancer study, said the seemingly contradictory results from different nutrition studies are confusing for scientists as well as consumers.

The current study by the Cancer Institute looked at the effects of 23 types of foods on health and mortality. The women were divided into four groups, depending on how many of the 23 healthy foods they ate each week.

Those who ate the fewest number of recommended foods, averaging only seven a week, had the highest death rate, which was then used as the base line to compare the death rates of women who ate increasingly more of the 23 foods.

A significant 18 percent decline in mortality was achieved by women who ate 10 of the recommended foods each week, only three more than the lowest group. 


Those who ate an average of 12 of the 23 foods each week had a reduction in their mortality rate of 29 percent, while those who averaged 15 of the foods reduced their overall death rate by 31 percent.

Compared with women who ate the least amount of the healthy foods, those who ate an average of 15 a week saw their risk of cancer decline by 40 percent, their risk of heart disease decline by 33 percent, and their risk of stroke decline by 42 percent.

"This is really good news," said Johanna Dwyer, professor of nutrition and medicine at Tufts University, who served on the federal government's dietary guidelines advisory committee. "From this study it looks as though some of the foods that have been recommended may in fact be associated with a decreased risk of mortality in women."

The study by the Cancer Institute included low-fat and high-fiber foods as part of the recommended healthy foods, but their effect could not be separated from the overall impact of a broader list of healthy products.


"Instead of having to focus on how much fat is in food, or focusing in great detail on exactly how much you're eating, this simply says that if you eat more of these foods then it will be associated with a lower risk of dying," Schatzkin said.

The institute findings also underscore the fact that the role of diet in health and disease is complicated, that many nutrients work in collaboration with other nutrients to produce their greatest beneficial effects, and that foods contain many nutrients that have yet to be discovered.
 
"This is an exciting study because it shows that a well-rounded diet, which concentrates on the healthiest foods, particularly fruits and vegetables, can improve health and reduce mortality," said Meir Stampfer, professor of nutrition and epidemiology at Harvard School of Public Health.  Stampfer, also a member of the federal government's advisory committee on  recommended dietary guidelines, said the Food Pyramid should be upgraded to reflect the importance of eating more fruits and vegetables.
 
In the recently reported colon cancer study, people who stayed on a low-fat, high-fiber diet for four years did not appear to have a lower rate of developing intestinal polyps than people not on the diet. Polyps are mushroom-like growths in the inner lining of the intestine that are associated with an increased risk of colon cancer.

The problem with the colon-cancer study is that it only looked at part of the cancer process for a short period of time, and did not look at whether a low-fat, high-fiber diet could prevent polyps from starting in the first place, or if the diet prevented them from going on to cancer after they have cropped up, Schatzkin said.

Furthermore, numerous population studies have confirmed that a low-fat, high-fiber diet significantly reduces the risk of heart disease, he said.  "We need, as much as possible, to try and bring these findings together and make consistent and coherent statements that help people to lead their lives sensibly," he said.

"You shouldn't toss out fiber based on one study," Schatzkin said. "It's prudent to try and maintain a fiber-rich diet in terms of such foods as vegetables, legumes and whole grains. Perhaps the evidence for simply adding cereal bran to your breakfast is less convincing than that for adopting a broader fiber diet."

Dwyer said that the Cancer Institute study should help clear up some of the confusion about food because it provides strong support for a growing body of evidence showing that a diet rich in fruits and vegetables and low in fat is good for people.

A sensible diet is one that reduces the consumption of red meat and animal and saturated fats, and increases the intake of fruits, vegetables, poultry, fish and whole grains, Schatzkin said.
"That is likely to lead to a reduced risk of cardiovascular disease and also diabetes, while reducing the overall mortality risk," he said.  Other strategies include at least a moderate level of physical acitivity and cancer screening for people at high risk.

In the NCI study, factors, such as smoking, alcohol consumption, exercise, age, ethnicity, weight, illness and physical activity were balanced out to reduce their influence on the role of diet in health.

The women who ate the healthiest diets were not sticklers for strict diets.  They were slightly older, more educated and physically active, likely to drink alcohol, use vitamin supplements, and they tended not to be smokers. They also had a lower fat intake.

Top of page

Pam's Recipes

Pam was diagnosed with M.S. 25 years ago. She learned more science at that time to find if there could be some way in which her progressive M.S.could be slowed down. Discovering the work of Professor Michael Crawford who worked with A.R.M.S.at the time she broadened her work to include nutrition and has been helping others in Dundee for some time. It seems as if something must have helped, whether it be diet , H.B.O.or a combination of the two, for her symptoms are much reduced.

Pam has sent menus and recipes to help you to follow a sensible eating plan if you have M.S.

Salad dressing

One of the most important things to watch is the amount of E.F.A.s eaten. The equivalent of two tablespoons of sunflower oil a day is recommended.

It is a good idea to have some of it in the form of a salad dressing to pour on salad or cooked vegetables. It is easiest to make up a quantity in a bottle and store in the fridge to use as you need it.

Sunflower Salad Dressing
Pour 2 fluid ounces of vinegar into the bottle.
Add a teaspoonful of mustard.
Shake well then add 8 fluid ounces of sunflower oil.
Give the bottle a good shake each time it is used.
Adding herbs to the dressing makes it tastier.

3 teaspoons of this dressing on a portion of vegetables at one meal is enough and supplies a third of the day's need.

 

THREE FISH RECIPES USING YOUR MICROWAVE

SIMPLE MUSTARD HERRING
1 tbs. sunflower oil
1 tbs. lemon juice
31evel tsp. made mustard
2 herring
1 tbs. flour
Mix the oil, lemon juice and mustard in a flat microwave dish large enough to hold the herring side by side. Coat the herring with the flour, place them in the dish and turn over to coat them with the flavoured oil. Cover and cook on full power for 3-4 minutes. Leave to stand for 2 minutes before serving.

 

STUFFED HERRING
2 herring
l banana
4tbs. natural yoghurt
2tsp. cornflour
ltsp. curry powder
Split the banana in half lengthways. Lay one banana half on each herring then fold the fish over it. Place them in a microwave dish. Blend the curry powder and cornflour into the yoghurt then pour it onto the herring. Cover the dish and microwave on full power for 3-4 minutes. Allow to rest for 2 minutes before serving.

 

LEAFY TROUT  
1 trout
3 large lettuce or spinach leaves
3 mushrooms chopped
3 tbs. natural yoghurt
1 finely chopped onion
Place the lettuce or spinach leaves in a microwave dish and cook on full power for 1 minute. Mix the mushrooms onion and yoghurt together, spread the mixture on the trout, then wrap in the leaves and cook on full powers. Place in the dish with two tablespoons of water. Cook on full power for seven minutes. Leave to stand for 1 minute.

Suggested menus for a week

Pam Hynd

New!Click the buttons below for some diet links to other websites.
These will open in a new window.
Food factsheets Downloadable fact-sheets on many nutritional topics from the British Dietetic Society
Calories/energy tracker Provides interactive information on your diet quality, physical activity status, etc
"Food for thought" "Food for thought" from the US MS Society
"Ten principals" "Ten important dietary principles for health" from NS3UK Ltd
"Nature's antidepressants" "Scientists back nature's antidepressants"
from BBC co uk
"Food & Nutrition" USDA Food and Nutrition Information Centre

 

Multiple Sclerosis Therapy Centres (Scotland) Home Page

This page was last updated on 16 April 2008

FAQ Site map Home M S HBO

About us

The Centres Diet and MS Support Links